STILWELL, Okla. — My tribal enrollment card was issued March 19, 2025. In the photo I’m smiling, wearing a zip-up OU jacket, and under my name it says “Tribal Member” just above my address.
The card comes from the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma, a tribe recognized by Congress in 1946 and headquartered in Tahlequah. Its Tribal Council has nine district seats, one for each district of the old Cherokee Nation. Tomorrow, Nov. 2, the UKB holds its election. In August I filed to run for the Flint District seat, but my name won’t be on the ballot.
The UKB Constitution calls the Council the band’s “supreme governing body.” The bylaws say the treasurer pays out the band’s money “in accordance with the vote of the Council.” For Flint District residents, the person holding that seat votes on those decisions, including how tribal money is spent.
I registered as a candidate Aug. 14. A challenge to my candidacy followed. The Election Board’s case is titled Kristie Bradley v. Troy Littledeer, and the band’s Tribal Court webpage lists Bradley as Tribal Court Administrator.
The election ordinance says “any candidate or eligible voter” may bring a challenge. In my court filings, I asked for the records showing the challenger qualified to bring one. No court has required the Board to produce them.
I asked the Board in writing for the challenge petition and its records on Aug. 28 and again on Sept. 4. The answers came from the Board’s lawyer, Justin T. Vann.
On Sept. 2, the Election Board held its hearing at the John Hair Cultural Center in Tahlequah. I was there. About 10 minutes went to the challenger, followed by roughly an hour and 35 minutes of questions for me. At one point Vann showed me a document from the Cherokee Nation with the person’s name blacked out and asked me about it.
The Board emailed its decision Sept. 8. A certified copy came in an envelope postmarked Sept. 8, processed in Tulsa Sept. 10, and delivered to me Sept. 11. The packet showed the challenge had its own case number at the Board, 2026-CONTEST-01, and its certificate of service had a printed name, “Justin T. Vann/Staff,” with no signature above it. The Board ruled that I hadn’t been an “exclusive member” for five years before I filed. The ordinance defines an exclusive member as a member who can prove one-quarter or more Cherokee blood and isn’t enrolled in any other tribe. My Certificate of Degree of Indian Blood lists 63/64 Cherokee.
The rule the Board used, Section 501(A)(3)(b), says a candidate must “be an exclusive member of the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma for a period of not less than five (5) years prior to filing.” The Board reads that to mean the five years have to run right up to the day I filed. The rule doesn’t say that. I’m not asking anyone to add up pieces of time. My UKB membership ran more than seven years without a break, starting July 9, 2005, and all of it came before I filed. That’s what I’ve argued in court, and the Board disagrees.
What I’ve argued is that if a rule keeps someone off the ballot, the ordinance has to say it, not imply it. Section 102 says the ordinance is enacted “pursuant to the authority contained in the Constitution and By-laws” and that “nothing in this Election Ordinance shall be changed from the date candidate registration opens for an election until the final election results are officially certified by the Election Board.” Section 104 defines 15 terms, and “prior to filing” isn’t one of them. Section 211 lets the Board choose its own process only “[w]henever no procedure is specifically provided.” The qualifications for office are written out in Section 501, so there’s no gap for the Board to fill. In its motion emailed Sept. 25, the Board wrote, “It was decided by the Election Board that the legislative intent and plain and ordinary reading of that provision should be continuous and direct in time with the filing.” On Oct. 5, in an opinion on a different election question, the band’s Attorney General wrote that “[t]he Election Board is not a UKB legislature and it cannot make law that contradicts a statute passed by Council.”
I filed my case in UKB District Court on Sept. 11 without a lawyer and have represented myself since. I filed an amended complaint Sept. 14.
On Sept. 25, Vann’s office emailed the Board’s motion to strike and dismiss my case, with a copy to the Tribal Council’s lawyer, Victoria Holland. The motion was file-stamped Sept. 29. At the Sept. 30 hearing before District Judge Charles Tripp, Holland appeared for the Council and asked to be heard. The judge asked me whether I knew about that request. I didn’t. The deputy court clerk later wrote me that, as far as she knew, no court reporter was provided that day, and that she herself wasn’t there.
I emailed my written objection to the Council’s participation on Oct. 1. It was file-stamped Oct. 6. The deputy clerk wrote that she had been out of the office the week before.
On Oct. 13, Judge Tripp dismissed my case because the Tribal Council hadn’t been added as a party. His order says, “The Court orally ordered the Plaintiff to add the Tribal Council as a party.” I don’t recall an order to add the Council. My objection filed Oct. 6 describes the hearing as I understood it, and the transcript will show what was said. The same order ends, “Therefore, the decision of the United Keetoowah Band Election Board is upheld.” My notice of appeal to the UKB Supreme Court was file-stamped Oct. 15.
On Oct. 19, Lighthorse Director Charlie Dreadfulwater emailed me that the deputy clerk “is no longer employed with the tribe, so any further correspondence can be sent to my email, and I will get it to the courts.” On Oct. 20, I sent him my motion asking the court to keep my place in the Flint race while my appeal is pending, and I asked for a ruling by Oct. 23. He replied that day: “These will be filed when I return from training with the date stamp of when you emailed them to me.” As of tonight, I haven’t received a ruling on that motion.
On Oct. 28, Holland filed a motion for the Council arguing that I’m not a member of the band at all. It asks that my case “be dismissed with prejudice, and any appeal should be denied.” The motion points to a 2012 relinquishment form and to Council Resolution 12-UKB-12c. That resolution says the Council “does approve to recognize and acknowledge the relinquishment of 9 members from Keetoowah Tribal Membership.”
Attached to the Council’s motion were pages from my enrollment file showing my full Social Security number. I asked the court to seal or redact them. Holland replied by email that she had “no objection to sealing and redacting that information.” On Oct. 29, Judge Tripp ordered the number redacted and the unredacted pages “destroyed in an appropriate manner concerning confidential information.” My written answer to the Council’s motion was file-stamped the same day.
I keep a copy of one more page. It comes from the band’s 1949 base roll, the list the UKB’s 1950 Constitution uses to define its membership. The names are typed in capital letters. One line reads LITTLEDEER, SAM, then STILWELL, OK., then 4/4. Sam Littledeer was my great-grandfather.
Tomorrow’s vote runs under the same ordinance. As far as I know, one name is on the Flint list. Section 602 says, “Any candidate who is unopposed shall be deemed to be elected.” In a midterm district election, it adds, “the unopposed candidate will not have an election in that district only.”
My appeal is still pending. So is the Council’s motion, along with several of my own requests. The card, with the band’s seal in the upper left corner and my signature across the bottom, is good until March 19, 2029.
The Council approved this election ordinance Dec. 6, 2025, in Resolution 25-UKB-132. The resolution lists seven votes yes, none no and four abstaining. If you’re a UKB member, your Council representative votes on laws like this one, and most of us never read them before they pass. Ask your representative for a copy. Ask what it says and how they voted. Then remember the answer the next time that seat is on your ballot.
SOURCES
Constitution and By-Laws of the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma (1950): Constitution Art. IV, Sec. 1; Art. V, Secs. 1-2; By-Laws Art. I, Sec. 4.
Corporate Charter of the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma (1950), preamble (recognition under the Act of Aug. 10, 1946).
2025 UKB Election Ordinance, Sections 102, 104, 211, 501(A)(3)(b), 508 and 602.
Resolution 25-UKB-132, approving the 2025 UKB Election Ordinance, Dec. 6, 2025.
Election Board decision, Kristie Bradley v. Troy Littledeer, Case No. 2026-CONTEST-01, Sept. 8, 2026, with certified-mail envelope and certificate of service.
Complaint (file-stamped Sept. 11, 2026) and
Amended Complaint (file-stamped Sept. 14, 2026), UKB District Court Case No. CV-2026-04.
Election Board Response, Motion to Strike and Motion to Dismiss, Case No. CV-2026-04, emailed Sept. 25, 2026, file-stamped Sept. 29, 2026, Paragraph 11(f).
Attorney General Opinion No. 2026-02, Oct. 5, 2026.
Petitioner’s Objection to Participation by Non-Party Tribal Council, Case No. CV-2026-04, file-stamped Oct. 6, 2026.
Decision on Election Board Challenge, Case No. CV-2026-04, filed Oct. 13, 2026.
Notice of Appeal, Case No. CV-2026-04, file-stamped Oct. 15, 2026.
Tribal Council Motion to Intervene and Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Standing and Mootness, with Exhibit 2 (Resolution 12-UKB-12c), Case No. CV-2026-04, filed Oct. 28, 2026.
Petitioner’s Response in Opposition, Case No. CV-2026-04, file-stamped Oct. 29, 2026.
Minute Order, Case No. CV-2026-04, filed Oct. 29, 2026.
Emails to the author from Deputy Court Clerk Jennifer Hawkins (Oct. 6 and Oct. 13, 2026), Lighthorse Director Charlie Dreadfulwater (Oct. 19 and Oct. 20, 2026) and Council attorney Victoria Proctor (Oct. 29, 2026).
Author’s written requests to the Election Board, Aug. 28 and Sept. 4, 2026.
UKB Tribal Enrollment card, Troy Allen Littledeer, issued March 19, 2025.
Certificate of Degree of Indian Blood, Troy Allen Littledeer, amended Nov. 13, 1991.
Page of the 1949 UKB base roll listing Sam Littledeer (copy held by the author).
Author’s firsthand observation, UKB Election Board hearing, Sept. 2, 2026, and District Court hearing, Sept. 30, 2026.
UKB Tribal Court webpage, ukb-nsn.gov/ukbtribalcourt.




